| DANCE ENSEMBLE 1 (Polka, Gypsies, Angels, Toys) | Aaliyah Jaquez |
| Mistress Mary | Abbi Robertson (understudy Heather Loomis) |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Abby Howland |
| Townspeople and Elves | Abby Post |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Abby Post |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Adelie Rahadja |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 3 (Waltz, Mechanical Dolls) | Adelyn Manning |
| Little Jack Horner | Alexia Lade |
| Townspeople and Elves | Andy Nazzarro (not an elf) |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Autumn Baker |
| Sheep | Ava Williams |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Ava Williams |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Avery McElhinney |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Caitlyn Steen |
| Townspeople and Elves | Callee McArdie |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 1 (Polka, Gypsies, Angels, Toys) | Camila Dominguez |
| Sheep | Cassie Kempf |
| Townspeople and Elves | Chloe Jameson |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Chloe Jameson |
| Townspeople and Elves | Clara Wilder |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Clara Wilder |
| Grumio | Dillan Van Vliet |
| Townspeople and Elves | Eden Lunt |
| Jack Be Nimble | Elise Kirschner |
| Sheep | Emma Peshlakai |
| Townspeople and Elves | Emme DeJesus |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Emme DeJesus |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 3 (Waltz, Mechanical Dolls) | Gemma Lane |
| Widow Piper | Genevieve Jenkins |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 1 (Polka, Gypsies, Angels, Toys) | Harper Manning |
| Lamb | Hazel Bagley |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Hazel Bagley |
| Alan | Isaac Sainz |
| Sheep | Isla Pun |
| Tom Tom the Piper’s Son | Joey McVey |
| Little Betty Blue | Kaia Honsberger |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Katie Ho |
| Jill | Katie Kirshner |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Katie Wickham |
| Lamb | Lacy Seville |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Lacy Seville |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 1 (Polka, Gypsies, Angels, Toys) | Lancey Gerak |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 3 (Waltz, Mechanical Dolls) | Laurel Gump |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Leila Heiselman |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Lillee Eaton |
| Little Bo Peep | Lola Roseland |
| Townspeople and Elves | Maiden Joy |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 3 (Waltz, Mechanical Dolls) | Maliyah Owens |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 3 (Waltz, Mechanical Dolls) | Mary Keogh |
| Inspector Marmaduke | Maverick Joy |
| Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater | Maverick Joy |
| Townspeople and Elves | McKenzie McEldowney |
| Roderigo | Meaghan Keogh |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Michael Lunt |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Mikayla Dennen (Ballerina Doll) |
| Townspeople and Elves | Nancy Davis (not an elf) |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 2 (Waltz, Toy Soldiers) | Naomi Manasco |
| Barnaby | Nicholas McVey |
| Mary Had a Little Lamb | Nina Honsberger |
| Goldilocks | Olivia Manning |
| Little Red Riding Hood | Rachel Irwin Rios |
| Townspeople and Elves | Rhonda Boynkin (not an elf) |
| Master Toymaker | Robert Strahota |
| Townspeople and Elves | Ruthie Bates |
| Townspeople and Elves | Sadie Kopa |
| Dancing Trees and Spiders | Sadie Kopa |
| Mother Spider | Samantha Jagger |
| Little Miss Muffet | Selah Grey |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 1 (Polka, Gypsies, Angels, Toys) | Sonia Honsberger (Dance Assistant for all dance rehearsals) |
| Jack | Teddy Williams |
| Gonzorgo | Tessa LaMar |
| Little Boy Blue | Titus Roberson |
| DANCE ENSEMBLE 1 (Polka, Gypsies, Angels, Toys) | Tracy Snider |
